Swinging Over the Top in Golf: Is It Always a Bad Thing?

If you’ve ever taken a golf lesson or watched a tutorial, you’ve probably heard that “swinging over the top” is something you should avoid. Most instructors say this move causes slices, weak shots, and inconsistency. But some golfers—and even a few coaches—believe that swinging over the top can actually work for certain players. So, is it really all bad?

What Is Swinging Over the Top?

Swinging over the top happens when a golfer’s club moves outside the intended swing path on the way down, cutting across the ball. This is why so many golfers who struggle with this move end up slicing the ball to the right (for right-handed players). It’s usually seen as a sign of bad mechanics, but it’s not always that simple.

Why Most Coaches Teach Against It

Most golf instructors say an over-the-top motion leads to problems like:

• Loss of Power: Cutting across the ball reduces distance.
• Slicing: The ball spins sideways instead of going straight.
• Inconsistency: It’s hard to repeat the same swing with a steep angle.

Because of this, many lessons focus on fixing this move by teaching players to drop the club more inside during the downswing.

When Swinging Over the Top Might Actually Work

Some golfers—especially those with slower swing speeds—find that an over-the-top move helps them hit the ball more solidly. Here’s why:

• Better Contact: For some players, swinging slightly over the top can help square the clubface at impact.
• More Fade Control: While it may not be ideal for long drives, an over-the-top move can produce a controlled fade (a gentle left-to-right shot for right-handers).
• Less Timing Required: Some players struggle with getting the club in the “perfect” inside path, so an over-the-top motion feels more natural.

The Bottom Line

While the traditional golf swing promotes a more inside path, some players find success by embracing an over-the-top move. It depends on your natural swing style, body mechanics, and what helps you hit the ball best. Instead of worrying about what’s “correct,” focus on what works for you. After all, the goal in golf is to get the ball in the hole—not to have the prettiest swing!